Retail sales figures for January will give the Treasury a fright. A fall of 8% was much larger than the more modest 3% expected by City economists and reveals how shoppers, when confronted by a third lockdown, were reluctant to keep calm and carry on.
There was a faint hope that after a disastrous Christmas period, and a year that ranked as the worst for consumer spending on record, we might see retailers start 2021 with a fresh set of wings. It was not to be.
While the slump in spending was not as great as during the first lockdown, any hopes of a milder drop in sales were snuffed out by the closure of all non-essential shops and the daily reports of rising infection levels and cases of Covid-19 cases that made it clear the lockdown would last for several months.
Another factor preying on the minds of consumers was government resistance to upgrading its financial support package. Calls to extend the uplift in universal credit beyond April, and likewise the furlough scheme, have been rebuffed so far.
Q&A
What is the Office for Budget Responsibility?
The Office for Budget Responsibility is the government’s independent forecaster, which gives its verdict on the outlook for growth and the public finances twice a year.
The forecasts are published to coincide with the chancellor’s two big set pieces of the year – the autumn budget and the spring statement – and takes into account the impact of any tax and spending measures announced in those statements.
The OBR also uses its public finances forecasts to judge the Treasury’s performance against the chancellor’s fiscal targets, stating whether or not it has a greater than 50% chance of hitting the targets under current policy.
It was established in 2010 by the then chancellor George Osborne with the aim of improving the credibility of the government’s official forecasts for growth. The forecasts were previously produced by the Treasury itself and often criticised for being unrealistic.
The OBR is led by three members of the budget responsibility committee, including chairman Robert Chote, a former director of the Institute for Fiscal Studies, with support from the OBR’s permanent staff of 27 civil servants.
Rishi Sunak is wedded to the idea that the best chancellor is one who makes clear they will adapt policies to match the course of the pandemic. What he has never seemed to realise is that a flexible approach can be viewed as procrastination and indecision.
Understandably, retailers and consumers would be reassured and have greater confidence if he offered a longer-term commitment. Today, at last, retailers will get an extension to the business rates holiday,in a statement by the chancellor.
The hope must be that next week ahead of the budget on 3 March Sunak agrees to go further and commit further funds to his broader rescue package.
According to the latest public finance figures, there is little excuse for him to hold back.
The Office for National Statistics estimates that borrowing over the 10 months from April 2020 to January 2021 was £270bn, around £70bn below the latest forecast from the Office for Budget Responsibility, the Treasury’s independent forecaster.
This calculation leaves out the likely cost of writing off billions of pounds of business loans made by the Treasury in the first months of the pandemic. The loan losses could add a further £30bn to the total. Yet the overall deficit will likely be well short of the much bigger annual drop that the OBR predicted.
Sign up to the daily Business Today email
The latest business surveys for February also provide some good news with firms looking ahead to better times. A rise from 41.2 in January to 49.8 this month in the IHD Markit CIPS purchasing managers index (PMI) shows industry planning to rebuild stocks and begin growing again. A figure in the index above 50 indicates expansion.
There were worrying signs from manufacturers, who said they were held back by delays to imports and exports at Britain’s ports. It was a clear message that without Brexit-related delays, the recovery could be so much stronger
Still, with more room for manoeuvre, Sunak could overcome many of the barriers to a recovery if he would only underwrite those businesses most in trouble for as long as the pandemic forces the government to impose restrictions.
Confidence is the key to a recovery on the high street as it is elsewhere in the economy. At the moment, Sunak is not going far enough to reassure those who are struggling that they will make it to the finish line.